When editors become complacent, errors are left to
fester on the page. Your reader deserves more than a hasty once-over by a
By Brent Thomas
Whatís the difference
between a great editor and a proofreader? No, itís not an industry joke, but
rather the focus of an Association Media & Publishing Annual Meeting session
on "The Habits of Highly Effective Copyeditors,Ē led by Joe Rominiecki, managing
editor, newsletters, ASAE; Samantha Whitehorne, managing editor, ASAE; and Lisa
Junker, director of publications and custom media, Stratton Publishing &
Marketing. According to the content leaders, great editors look beyond typos
and style guides to explore the finer points of copyediting, thus
differentiating themselves from the ranks of mere proofreaders.
I know what youíre asking
yourself: How much will this information cost me? If it were tangible, it would
be worth several times its weight in gold. Luckily, you cannot put a price
(aside from registration fees) on such an invaluable skillset as effective
The first piece of advice is
the key to any good relationship: mistrust. Specifically, learn to mistrust
yourself. When editors become complacent, errors are left to fester on the
page. Instead of skimming through the copy like yesterdayís news, slow down and
take a minute to doubt yourself. As slaves to the production schedule, this may
seem not only frustrating, but downright impossible. However, remember that the
copyeditor is the last line of defense, and your reader deserves more than a
hasty once-over. And aside from the usual typos and grammar blunders, it is
essential to double-check meaning and context.
Itís also important to
remember that you canít remember everything. You donít need to memorize your
style guide. It is meant to be a reference guide, so feel justified in referencing
With effective general
practices out of the way, the session proceeded to focus on "the basics.Ē After
all, the easiest things to fix are the easiest to miss. For instance, names,
titles, and designations are common in association publishing; remain
consistent to avoid confusion or embarrassing discrepancies. Also, pronouns
(their and his/her/it); relative pronouns (that and which); and abbreviations
(i.e. and e.g.) might seem self-explanatory, but are often overlooked to the
chagrin of copyeditors everywhere. Again, the important thing is to remain
vigilant and consistent.
Next up was punctuation. Effective
punctuation helps guide readers through treacherous terrain on the path to
comprehension. Use hyphens with potentially misleading words and phrases. Keep
correlative conjunctions parallel. Punctuate lists appropriately and
consistently. Forget the apostrophe when dealing with pronouns, letters, dates,
etc. Reconsider using that em dash. Donít forget about or overuse semicolons.
And please, donít splice sentences with commas. These rules and suggestions are
far from novel, but it never hurts to brush up on the particulars of
The content leaders then
went through a list of the "finer pointsĒ to remember. From word choice to
misplaced modifiers, these suggestions ran the gamut of style and structure.
For instance, always double-check the numbers when dealing with math. Watch out
for shifts in perspective. Avoid bogging down your writing with jargon and
clichés. Keep tabs on your indefinite pronouns. And just to lay the argument to
rest, feel free to split infinitives.
Two principal habits of
highly effective copyeditors were stressed throughout this session: Strive for
consistency and remain vigilant. Try posting your style guide on a wiki to
further promote these habits across your association. After all, not everyone
is passionate about the fine art of copyediting ó as surprising as that may be.
For additional resources related to this session, please visit http://bit.ly/amp11copyeditors.
Brent Thomas is editorial coordinator at Association
of Corporate Counsel (ACC). Association Media & Publishing thanks him for
covering this Annual Meeting session for our members who were unable to attend.