Google's AMP Poised to Take the Lead from Facebook's and Apple's Walled Gardens

Google's AMP Poised to Take the Lead from Facebook's and Apple's Walled Gardens
1/26/2016 3:59:37 PM

Google’s AMP Poised to Take the Lead from Facebook’s and Apple’s Walled Gardens

Hearing a lot about Google AMP lately? Here’s a good explanation of what it is and how publishers will use it.

By Frédéric Filloux

By the end of February, Google will deploy at full scale its Accelerated Mobile Pages project by sending search results to amp-html pages. Because it integrates all monetization instruments — advertising, analytics and now subscription systems — Google’s AMP is likely to rally scores of publishers.

Over 5,000 developers registered to the Github repository of Google’s Accelerated Mobile Pages (AMP) program. Some are just sniffing around; others actually work for large or small organizations and are truly committed to building something.

In a few weeks, Google will open the floodgates connecting AMP to its search engine. Twitter and Pinterest will follow. A request from a mobile phone will call an AMP-coded page (when available) that will load at blazing speed. That’s the plan. For a glimpse of what it will look like, try the demo version from your mobile, or add "/amp” at the end of any Guardian page’s URL. Tested from a poor mobile connection, the result is compelling.

How does Google pull this off? AMP redesigns core components of the Internet’s historic Hypertext Markup Language, now re-christened amp-html, and supports it with a massive distributed caching system in which Google hosts pages for a few seconds or hours, in multiple caches spread around the world to be closest to the user. All publishers have to do is provide two versions of their pages, one for direct access from a well-connected desktop, and an AMP version for mobile. It goes like this:

When a page is called from a mobile through search, Twitter or other, the user is directed to the super-fast page.(More about the whole concept in this AMP official blog.)

Google is reluctant to speculate about the number of publishers that will be on board when the AMP program launches late February. Expect several hundreds in Europe and in the United States. All the big players are working on AMP, from The New York Times to Vox Media; it will spread quickly as specifications cover more web components. As the number of publishers rises, the system will become more visible in Google search pages, thanks to a larger corpus of news elements coded in AMP.


The snowball effect will also apply for another simple reason: AMP-HTML coded items will show better in Google SERPs (Search Engine Results Pages.) If Google product managers adamantly insist on the absolute neutrality of Search, it is a known fact that rendering speed is a key contributor to better rankings. In itself, this factor should act as a powerful stimulus to create AMP pages.

Other incentives center on the monetization side of the program. On the advertising side, most ad servers (not just Google-owned DFP) will be able to send ads in AMP pages. Some work remains to be done on the formats that will be deemed acceptable in AMP pages.

Privately, Google people make no mystery of their intention to clean the advertising mess. They want to get rid of the invasive formats that, by ruining the user experience, contributed to the explosion of ad blockers and threatened a large segment of the digital economy. To that end, the AMP ecosystem is their weapon of choice.

Between Google’s AMP engineering team and the advertising community, interests collide. The former are focused on accelerating the rendering of mobile pages and restoring a decent user experience on mobile; the latter prioritizes value extraction of above all other considerations.

Even if the company won’t publicly admit it, Google plans to lean on AMP to curb advertising excesses on media sites — hence the initial idea to constrain the formats allowed in the AMP ecosystem. According to Google, pages that render four times faster on a smartphone will cause users to increase their page-views per session and to see more ads as a result.

For their part, ad buyers face pressure from creative people who want the splashiest possible formats to fit the (presumed) aspirations of their brands. From the mobile user’s perspective, fluffy ads translate into pages that take forever to load and into a strong incentive to jump elsewhere: about half of users will leave a mobile site that takes more than six to 10 seconds to load. Nevertheless, the advertising community now seems on board with the AMP project.

I’m not so sure that having on-board Internet nuisances such as Outbrain or Taboola is such good news. With remarkable consistency, these two disfigure thousands of sites across the world by inserting grotesque promotional or editorial recommendations in news pages. As for, it created many unseen-before video formats that should be rewarded by ad blocker companies for their ability to trigger user rejection. It will be interesting to watch how Google contains these companies’ propensity to impact user experience in such negative fashion.

For good measure, let’s also mention that AMP places a bet on native ads integration; Google will propose its own product as well as third party solutions such as the Polar platform.

From Google’s standpoint, the priority given to speed justifies a certain inflexibility in its drive to use AMP as the prime argument to get rid of bad ads. Even if some rapprochement is underway, the ad community seems a bit too slow to respond while publishers don’t feel like they are in a position to pressure them.

To me, the surest way to make progress is a decisive move from the creative advertising side. Instead of fighting for the status quo, agencies should devote more resources to come up with truly creative formats that fit AMP specs — and publishers should take the user’s side.


In building AMP, Google had to deal with the multiple flavors of analytics asked (and sometimes actually used) by publishers. News media have a strange relationship to analytics. They want to use most of them as if they would warrant performance.

But, unlike e-commerce sites, media are not culturally accustomed to make intensive use of data. Instead of embedding just a couple of analytics code segments in their pages, some sites end up using dozens of those. Such non-choice proves efficient at slowing down the rendering of these pages. Smartly, the AMP team decided early on to team up with Chartbeat, probably the preferred analytics tool in the news community. Today, multiple web metrics providers are on board, including Moat (who partners with Chartbeat), Nielsen, ComScore,, ClickTale, Adobe Analytics, etc. It is unclear, though, how AMP will be able to discourage publishers from installing too many of those.


One of the most complicated issues the AMP engineering team had to deal with was the implementation of paywalls. These are insistently asked by publishers ranging from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, and European publishers such as the FT or Les Echos. Due to the widely distributed architecture of AMP in which a single page could be replicated hundreds of times all over multiple caches, reproducing a metered system, the partial display of a story, or a login flow was quite a task.

The good news is: It’s done.

This week, AMP’s engineers will release the version 0.1 of the code that allows publishers to implement paywalls in the AMP ecosystem. This is a critical feature for the economy of quality news media — an advantage that Facebook’s Instant Articles or Apple’s News are nowhere near to offering.

How does AMP paywall support work? Let’s start with a simplistic sketch summing up today’s situation:

The main drawback is obvious: Each time users flush their cookies, they start over for free. That’s why the most stringent paywalls require a registration. This carries two advantages: Cheating is more difficult, and the user can be followed from one device to another. Then, why did so few publishers elect to not require a registration? Again: the non-choice syndrome. They want to win on both ends — subscription and advertising.

Summing up, when it comes to implementing paid subscriptions support, the AMP team has gone way further than expected. What is still a preliminary version of specs already allows numerous paywall fine-tuning possibilities.And there is more to come.

Frédéric Filloux is the founder and editor of the Monday Note. He invites Sidebar readers to request a free subscription. He is a graduate from the Bordeaux school of Journalism and lives in Paris. He’s a frequent speaker in various conferences.

Posted by: Frederic Filloux | Submit comment | Tell a friend


Share and enjoy:   Digg This   Facebook   Furl   Google Bookmarks   NewsVine   Reddit   SlashDot   Stumble Upon   Technorati   Yahoo Bookmark   Windows Live Bookmark
2/29/2016 1:34:30 AM
Very good post.
9/7/2016 7:20:17 AM
I am very glad to be here.It is so amazing and interesting.I wanna tell you that it is very helpful for us.Thanks for sharing such an awesome blog with us.I want to visit again.
9/28/2016 10:08:38 PM
Excellent read, Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?
10/1/2016 2:26:12 PM
I am hopeful that somebody can give me the homepage for the pokemon go coins as i am new to the game.
10/1/2016 5:35:42 PM
I am looking for some website that has free pokecoins generator for the game online.
10/4/2016 5:00:21 AM
I have gone through the article given here and from this I understood about Google’s Accelerated Mobile Pages project. I am a computer science student and I am doing a project in this topic, the information provided here helps me to complete my project.
10/28/2016 6:09:39 AM
A redesign of HTML is very much needed and its good news to hear that Google has come with an improved one. This will result in speedily rendering pages optimized for mobile devices which can then provide a decent web experience through phones. The article was good to know about the latest developments in internet communications and you have explained it well with diagrams which enable easy understanding.      
10/28/2016 6:12:01 AM
A redesign of HTML is very much needed and its good news to hear that Google has come with an improved one. This will result in speedily rendering pages optimized for mobile devices which can then provide a decent web experience through phones. The article was good to know about the latest developments in internet communications and you have explained it well with diagrams which enable easy understanding.
11/4/2016 2:26:56 PM
I really like your blog articles. Thanks for the insight you provide the readers!
11/12/2016 9:00:25 AM
Hi Frédéric Filloux, Much thanks for this extraordinary post, I am pretty sure about this information you shared because its really helpful for everyone.

11/15/2016 6:46:17 AM
I read deeply your article, the points you have mentioned in this article are useful. I am always pleased with what you bring to it very interesting and useful .
11/24/2016 6:42:40 AM

I read deeply your article, the points you have mentioned in this article are useful. I am always pleased with what you bring to it very interesting and useful .
12/1/2016 6:33:42 AM
ShowBox for Android is the best way to feel some real time while having some cup of tea/coffee with a lot of movies loaded on it already. So keep loving this movies app for long lasting entertainment to you and your family.
12/1/2016 10:59:14 PM
Nice one it was really good
12/9/2016 2:33:49 AM
I think your post is very interesting and mostly i keep looking for like this type of websites where i learn or get new concept. I am happy to visit on your site. Thanks to share it.
12/9/2016 2:34:48 AM
I really like the dear information you offer in your articles. I’m able to bookmark your site and show the kids check out up here generally. Im fairly positive theyre likely to be informed a great deal of new stuff here than anyone
12/14/2016 9:40:20 PM
penyubur sperma pria alami . layanan paket umroh dan ONH plus murah
12/19/2016 2:11:50 AM
Thanks a lot for the post. It has helped me get some nice ideas. I hope I will see some really good result soon.
12/19/2016 5:12:21 AM
We are No. 1 Assignment Help in Australia. Feel free to hire us for assignment writing in Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, Tasmania and Canberra Australia.
12/19/2016 5:30:39 AM
"We are No. 1 in Dissertation Writing Help & Writing Service - Thesis Writing Help and Writing Service. You can also hire us for top quality dissertations."
12/19/2016 5:51:20 AM
Our website is No. 1 in UK for Assignment Help. You can also hire us Thesis writing in UK, Dissertation writing and other Assignment Writing Services and Help.
12/19/2016 6:35:56 AM
Our website is No. 1 in Nursing Essay Writing and Nursing Assignment Help. Feel free to hire us for Nursing Homework Help and Assistance.
12/19/2016 6:46:01 AM
We are No. 1 R Programming Assignment Help. You can also hire us for R programming projects, assignments and homework.
12/19/2016 6:53:35 AM
We are No. 1 Mobile App Development. Feel free to hire us for Android Mobile Application Development and iOS Mobile Application Development.
12/21/2016 12:40:49 AM
I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
1/16/2017 4:52:42 AM
Thanks for sharing useful information for us.I really enjoyed reading your blog, you have lots of great content nice post. I learn some thing tougher on distinct blogs everyday
2/6/2017 9:06:34 AM
Google's AMP Poised to Take the Lead from Facebook's and Apple's Walled Gardens This post shows the current trend of apple walled gardens
2/7/2017 10:13:15 AM
To change the setting of window edge than tap here to change.
2/16/2017 4:33:15 AM
Very nice blog on this website! It is really difficult to find such a fantastic content with some useful information   
2/16/2017 10:04:23 AM
Solitaire is a fun card game to enjoy at all ages. Create stacks of cards on the solitaire board by stacking cards downward alternating color. Click through the stock cards to add extra cards to the solitaire game.
2/21/2017 10:55:16 AM
CASE STUDY HELP & CASE STUDY ONLINE HELP What a case study is and what it requires? Case study assignment is a must assignment that every student get.
2/22/2017 2:22:35 AM
articles that you provide a very interesting and very useful for my admin and pardon me permission to share articles herein may be useful and helpful
2/22/2017 10:56:46 AM
Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.
2/22/2017 10:57:24 AM
A very nice website thanks for sharing such a great information with us. I wish you all a very
2/24/2017 8:29:44 AM
The Borderlands series is one of the best in the lot of action gaming. Now the third installment of the series is about to release with the
addition of two new varieties of items including the laser gun and I am waiting for this game to release to check it out myself. Hope it lives
up to our expectations.
Submit a Comment
Web Site  (optional)
HTML tags are not allowed.


© Copyright 2017, Association Media and Publishing. All rights reserved.